Tue 9 Feb 2010
Simon Weston: Alternative Energy solutions being thwarted by environmentalists
Posted by admin under Energy , Environment , Opinion , Simon Weston 1 Comment
It’s a cold and rainy day. We even had hail earlier. So I thought what a great day to write about energy, specifically wind and solar energy. After all according to “the One” these are the two types of energy that will finally free us of our “addiction to oil”, make us energy independent and stop the flow of our money to countries that use it to undermine our way of life. Every president since Nixon has espoused the same goal and never come close to freeing us of our addiction to oil. We even created a new cabinet position, the Department of Energy, to help us become energy independent. Forty years on and all we did is create another huge bureaucracy that does a good job of keeping track of our ever increasing addiction to oil but little else.
Call me crazy but I think windmills that generate electricity should be placed where the wind blows frequently and that solar arrays should be built where the sun shines most of the time. You know the deserts of California, Arizona, Nevada, New Mexico and Texas. One would think that environmentalist and other proponents of “free” energy would think the same way. One would be wrong.
Take, for example, Senator Ted Kennedy. He was a big supporter of alternative forms of energy. Except of course, like most liberals, when it affected him directly. He successfully fought the placement of a wind farm off the coast of Cape Cod because it would have ruined the view from his summer home. Tall, ugly windmills are OK near Rosamond and Mojave, California but not so much off the coast of Cape Cod.
When California Senator Diane Feinstein found out that several huge solar arrays were proposed to be built in the Mojave Desert she immediately sprang into action. Not to support the solar arrays that would have generated mega-watts of clean energy for Southern California, but to have Congress pass a law that made millions of acres of the Mojave Desert an environmentally sensitive area and therefore off limits to any solar arrays. After all what is more important, a tortoise or people? Guess we know the answer to that question.
Recently, while on vacation, I happened to run across an article in the local newspaper titled “Solar project faces hurdles”. Local environmentalists are fighting the construction of a solar array in the Panoche Valley. It’s located in the eastern part of San Benito County. I never heard of it either. According to the article the Panoche Valley is “know mostly for cattle and barbed wire, a treeless landscape…….that turns green in the spring but for much of the year looks like rural Nevada”. In other words a barren and forlorn countryside but with lots of sunshine for most of the year; a perfect place for a solar power project, right.
Wrong; at least according to the environmentalists who are of course fighting it. The fact the project would generate enough pollution free energy to power 315,000 homes is irrelevant. The blunt nosed leopard lizard might be endangered and we can’t have that, can we?
As much as we all would like to be energy independent, and I am all for that, I think that at some point we are going to have to make some important choices and probably have to make some tradeoffs. Yes turtles and lizards are important but at the cost of humans not being able to heat and cool their homes? I don’t think so. Right now it the very people who tell us that we need to use alternative sources of energy are telling us to take our wind farms and solar power plants and put them where to sun doesn’t shine!
Simon Weston- Commentary
Simon Weston is a resident of Stevenson Ranch. His commentaries represent his own opinions and not necessarily the views of any organization he may be affiliated with or those of the West Ranch Beacon.






February 23rd, 2011 at 1:47 pm
Mr. Weston, please do your homework diligently before talking about a subject you know nothing about.
I live and farm in Panoche Valley. It is not only environmentalist who wish to protect this valley from industrial development – it’s the farmers and ranchers who would be forced out of business if this project is built.
Please allow me to give you some background information. Solargen Energy Inc. is a company created by venture capitalist with a history of taking advantage of government subsidies. They’ve bankrupted a drilling company, (Blast Engineering) and an ethanol company, (AE Biofuels). The founder, (Eric McAfee) has been heavily fined by the SEC for lying to investers. They have never built a single solar project.
We found out about this project when my neighbor, a dairy, was having work done on their property by PG&E. The PG&E tech asked, “What do you think of the solar project proposed for this project?” No one knew anything so we started doing research. Turns out the project was proposed for the entire 10,000 acres of the valley floor and including everyone’s property yet no one had been approached to sell except 5 landowners. They finally reduced the project to lands owned by the 5 (absentee) landowners that were willing to sell – 4,885 acres. The largest operational projects in the world are only 400-500 acres on average.
All of the remaining Panoche Valley landowners are people who own and operate farms and ranches in the valley. They will all be negatively impacted by the proposed 24 hour per day, 6 day a week, 5 year construction period. Pile-drivers will be used to pount mounting posts 6′ into the ground for 4 million solar panels. The project site, which extends all the way from the east end to the west end of the valley, and up to the foothills to the north, will be illuminated throughout the night.
Yes, this is an arid environment during the summer and the people who currently steward the land take great pains to make sure there is vegetation covering all of the topsoil. We manage our grazing lands and experience incredible weight gain on the forage grown in the valley floor’s Class 1 soils – the highest fertility rating possible. The project will expose a huge part of the valley’s topsoil. The high winds that frequently blow cause topsoil erosion wherever vegetation is limited. Desertification is a very real threat.
The excessive dust, noise and light is going to be a problem for our livestock. It’s going to be a problem for our local school, Panoche Valley Elementary, which is only 3/4 of a mile from the project site. It is a year-round school and the teacher lives on the grounds. It’s going to be a problem for all residents, who all live adjacent to, or within a short distance from, the project site. These are the immediate issues residents will experience. Also a problem is reduced fire protection,(we are over an hour away from the closest fire station)and water shortages & pollution, (we all access the same two aquifers that will be used to frequently clean 4 million panels, chemicals have been proposed for dust control, etc.).
I could go on but I hope this gives you an idea of the issues we will all face if this project is built. It doesn’t make sense to take away a viable, working food-production lands in lieu of a renewable energy. Our dependence on foreign food is growing. Do you propose increasing that dependence in order to reduce foreign oil dependence?
The amazing thing is none of this destruction is necessary. There are 30,000 acres already set aside in the Westlands CREZ (California Renewable Energy Zone) for renewable energy production. A mere 60 miles from Panoche Valley, (seconds in the time it takes energy to travel) the Westlands is retired ag land no longer viable due to salinity buildup in the soil. There are no communities that would be impacted, no threatened or endangered species that would be displaced. The only reason Solargen doesn’t want to build there is because it would cost them more to lease than to own.
Solargen can’t afford to build this project without the $360 million they qualify for in ARRA (American Recovery and Reinvestment Act) funds – your and my tax dollars. They already are in contract to purchase their 4 million solar panels from a Chinese manufacturer. Why, if they’ll be using American tax dollars, do they not have to buy American? But wait, it gets better. The Chinese manufacturer? They are Solargen’s #1 investor and are new to the solar panel manufacturing business.
As I said, there’s more but hopefully this gives you an idea of what’s at stake. Before we decimate American’s agricultural lands and biological resources, we should develop all designated renewable energy zones and rooftop space. Spain and Germany are the current world leaders in renewable energy production and they didn’t do it by ruining their precious resources. They offered subsidies to their citizens to install solar and created feed-in tariffs to force energy companies to buy excess energy produced from consumers.
Big solar = big energy. They don’t want us to have power over our own energy production. They want to maintain the monopoly they have over us and keep us “powerless”. Many of us Americans are tired of the incestuous relationship between government and the rich elite/big business. And for the record, I’m not a Republican or Democrate – I’m a Libertarian. The whole lot of them stink and they’re getting rich on the working class’s hard earned money, while we continue to struggle.
Looking forward to hearing your thoughts on these matters, and hopefully a new perspective.
Kim Williams
Your Family Farm
32615 Panoche Road
Panoche Valley
CA 95043